How to Ask Podcast Interview Questions Your Audience Actually Cares About
“Do you know so-and-so?”
“Yeah, I know so-and-so. How are their kids?”
Ever watched two people have that conversation on a podcast? The host is having a great time. The guest is having a great time. And you’re sitting there wondering who these people are and why you’re still watching.
You can have an incredible studio, an amazing guest, and beautiful production and still end up with an interview nobody wants to finish. Somewhere along the way, you forgot who the conversation was for.
Here’s what I tell hosts at AZ Pod Studio: Before you ask your next question, picture one of your listeners sitting in the room with you. What would they lean forward and ask if you handed them the mic? That’s usually a pretty good question.
Three questions to ask yourself before every podcast interview
1. Who is this particular episode for?
Get specific enough that you can picture somebody. “Entrepreneurs” is a start. “Someone who just landed their biggest client and is nervous about making their first hire” gives you an interview.
Your show can have the same target listener every week. What changes from episode to episode is the problem you’re helping that person work through.
2. What does that person need from this conversation?
Sometimes they need a practical answer. Sometimes they need encouragement. Sometimes they need to hear somebody they respect admit, “Yeah, I went through that too.”
If you’re unsure, try typing the listener’s problem into YouTube or Google. Read how people phrase the question. You might have written “discuss business growth” on your prep sheet. Your listener might be asking, “How do I know I can afford my first employee?” You could open the interview with that exact question.
3. What can this guest tell them from firsthand experience?
Look for a decision the guest actually made, a mistake they paid for, or a moment they remember clearly. That gives your listener a reason to hear this person answer the question.
Here’s a sentence you can steal for your prep sheet: “This episode is for someone who ____. By the end, I want them to understand ____. My guest can help because they’ve personally ____.”
What does a good podcast interview question sound like?
Let’s say you’re interviewing an entrepreneur. You could ask, “How did you build your company?” That’s a fair question. It also asks your guest to edit ten years of their life on the spot. They could spend the next five minutes telling you how they came up with the name.
Now try this: “When you were first starting out, what’s one mistake that almost put you under?”
Give them time to tell that story. Then ask, “If somebody listening is about to make that same mistake, what should they look for?”
See the difference? The first question gets you to a moment. The follow-up gives the person listening something they can do with it.
The best part of the interview might be three follow-up questions away
Imagine your guest says, “We almost went under in our second year.” You look down at your prep sheet. The next question says, “What advice would you give aspiring entrepreneurs?”
Hang on. They just told you they almost lost the company. If your listener were sitting there, would they really change the subject?
I’d stay there a little longer:
“When did you first realize you might not make it?”
“What did you do the next morning?”
“Looking back, what warning sign would you tell another owner to watch for?”
Listen to what happens across those three questions. You get the moment they knew, the decision they made, and the lesson somebody else can use. Any one of those answers could be the reason a listener remembers the episode.
Would you ask the same guest the same question for two different listeners?
Here’s a test I use. Put an 89-year-old woman on one side of the room and a 15-year-old boy on the other. Now put the same guest in front of them. Would you automatically ask the guest the same question for both people?
I wouldn’t. I’d want to know what brought each of them into the room.
Say the guest is a musician. The teenager might be trying to get through his first open mic. He wants to ask, “What did you do when your hands started shaking?” The woman might have spent 60 years wanting to play piano and finally has the time. Her question might be, “If I started today, what’s one song I could actually learn?” Same guest. You could make a terrific episode out of either question. It depends on who’s listening.
That’s where your curiosity belongs. Have fun with your guest. Follow the story that surprises you. And when you get the feeling there’s something your listener would love to ask, be their tour guide and ask it for them.
Common questions about interviewing podcast guests
How do I interview a guest I already know without leaving listeners out?
Give the listener one sentence of context before you get into the story. “You and I met the week you were deciding whether to close the shop. What happened that week?” Now the history between you gives the audience a way into the conversation.
Should I write out my podcast interview questions in advance?
Write down your opening question, a few things your listener wants to understand, and one takeaway you hope they leave with. Keep that sheet where you can glance at it. When the guest says something you want to know more about, give yourself room to follow it.
What can I ask when a guest gives a vague answer?
Try “Can you take me back to a time that actually happened?” If they say communication matters, ask, “What did you say when you had to have that conversation?” Now the listener gets to hear what the advice sounds like in real life.
Planning an interview for your own show? At AZ Pod Studio in Phoenix, we help hosts work through the audience, the guest, and the questions before recording day. See how we plan and produce a podcast at AZ Pod Studio.



Comments